Most retirement calculators assume a flat 12% annual return. That makes planning look easy—but it hides the real drivers of success: sequence of returns, taxes, withdrawal rules, and market regimes.
The Problem With Fixed Returns
- Sequence Risk: Two retirement plans with identical 12% average returns can have wildly different outcomes. If you experience poor returns early in retirement when withdrawals are happening, your portfolio may never recover—even if later returns are strong. Order matters as much as average.
- Tax Impact: Short-term capital gains (STCG) and long-term capital gains (LTCG) taxes materially change post-tax outcomes. Higher-turnover strategies like momentum can face significantly higher tax drag, reducing actual returns below the assumed 12%.
- Market Crashes: A 2008-style prolonged drawdown early in your retirement can derail even a well-funded plan. If you're forced to sell during a 40% market decline to fund living expenses, the permanent capital loss can be devastating—regardless of long-term average returns.
- False Confidence: Fixed return models create a false sense of security. They suggest retirement planning is simple math, when in reality it's a complex interplay of timing, market conditions, and behavioral factors.
A Better Approach
- Use Historical Return Series: Instead of assuming 12% every year, use actual NIFTY TRI historical data or systematic strategy backtests. This captures real volatility, drawdowns, and recovery patterns that flat assumptions miss entirely.
- Model After-Tax, After-Withdrawal Cash Flows: Build your plan around realistic cash flows that account for STCG/LTCG taxes and withdrawal timing. See what your actual spendable income looks like under different scenarios, not just gross returns.
- Run Comprehensive Stress Tests: Test your plan against historical crises (2008 financial crisis, 2020 COVID crash) and run percentile scenarios to understand the range of possible outcomes. Know your worst-case scenarios, not just the average case.
Build a Reality-Based Retirement Plan
Use StratLab to backtest retirement scenarios with historical data, realistic tax assumptions, withdrawal rules, and stress tests—not just simplified 12% assumptions
Start Free Retirement Planning
Disclaimer: This article is educational only and not investment advice. Every investor's situation is different. Consult a qualified financial advisor for personalized retirement planning guidance.